What Really Makes The Boston Marathon So Special?

On the Phedippidations Message Board a discussion about what makes the Boston Marathon special popped up in part because of Steve Walker’s recent opportunity to run the race again this year. The following is an excerpt from a runner and podcaster who I have great respect for who goes by the name dumprunner on the message board. He writes:

I am probably contrarian but Boston is  simply not as special as it is made out to be. It has history, great crowds, is extremely well run (that could be said for a lot of marathons) and a great booming voice at mile 22.

But the minute I finished, I had no desire ever to run it again and that hasn’t changed.

My mind filled with dozens of loosely connected images as I thought about how I would respond to his comment, arriving at what might be only described as a schizophrenic pattern of thought, which for those of you who read my missives know is nothing new for me.

The most amazing experiences for me at Boston always come at the point in time when I land at Logan International Airport in Boston. As soon as I step off of the plane, I see a sudden shift in the morphology of the general population around me. Lean, clean shaven, athletic folks abound, carrying water bottles and wearing t-shirts espousing the various running clubs or races that they have been affiliated with. To your right and left are small groups of folks chatting quietly and confidently while chewing on a Clif Bar or a baggie filled with celery. In truth, if you are flying into Boston, you only need to look around the plane you are flying in on to see hints of this already.  These people need no medals swung loosely around their necks for us to understand just how talented these runners are. It isn’t the Tevas on their feet or the small duffel bag on their shoulder that gives them away. Nor is it the cross country t-shirts marked simply by the graphic of two adjacent C’s split horizontally by an arrow. In fact it’s in their confidence.

What makes Boston differnent than any other marathon is that everyone that has qualified for this race has already done the work to get here. There is nothing left to worry about or be concerned about aside from any demons that we all continue to carry around with us in search of our next PR, and if it should be at Boston, so much the better. Boston is about celebrating your accomplishments, setting new standards or simply not looking silly when running next to legends of the sport.

Two years ago, I reported from La Guardia airport on my way to support @texafornia, @jettpack, @simplystu, IronWil and the rest of my friends on Team Race Athlete at Ironman Wisconsin. The piles of bike boxes stacked 6 feet high in the ticketing area at La Guardia told me that I was part of something much larger than just another race. These are the tools of battle, packaged with care and sitting innocuously just waiting to leap out before traveling 112 miles at 22+ mph over the roads around Madison. Arriving in Boston is very similar, and unlike NYC, Chicago and Los Angeles, where people wander aimlessly around the expo, the Boston Marathon Expo is very much business as usual, with runners getting in, and getting out as efficiently as possible. Remember, these folks have all done this before. Perhaps then, Boston is really about being humble, because everyone there knows what they are capable of accomplishing.

The charity entries have definitely changed this atmosphere, which is why I actually discourage folks from running Boston under a charity entry – and I founded a charity endurance training program. I simply think that there’s nothing wrong with one marathon to be held aside for those age-groupers who purely by genetic gift or training have risen to this level of performance.

All marathons have their personalities and Boston is no exception. I give great complements to those, like dumprunner and Avi who PR’d on that course and even more so to those who do so while running negative splits. The course is no joke, but it is after all, just another course, 26.2 miles long.

To me what is really special about Boston is that for a few hours you can count yourself among those who perform at that level and, especially for those who do not come by this naturally, that you have a community that is singularly committed to celebrate all of the sacrifices that you made to get there – all of those mornings waking up and running at 5am so that you could complete your run before you had to start your normal working day and before attending to all of your other responsibilities that did not take time off just because you were “in training”.

In short, The Boston Marathon is the 360 tomahawk dunk of running. Not everyone can do it, but when you do, the world takes notice and you can’t help but feel that it was all worth it.

Congratulations to all who will be participating in Boston in April. Again, as always, I am humbled by your achievement.



Comments

Joe Garland said on March 29th, 2009 at 12:09 pm

I like your perspective. Maybe Boston should be off-limits to the charity folks.

The BQ, of course, is itself arbitrary. It once was 2:50 for all men. Now, it’s a goal well below or well above many runners. But for those who have a shot, it is indeed a great thing to shoot for. How many have been sooooo close and have re-doubled their efforts successfully the next time out and thus are justifiably proud to be in Hopkinton on Patriots’ Day?

Coach Adam said on March 29th, 2009 at 12:17 pm

Agreed. Most things in athletics were originally arbitrary or based on a thumb measured against the wind. In today’s world we’d do focus groups and analyses and still probably wouldn’t get as close or make things as interesting. Don’t get me wrong, I applaud Boston for using the marathon to help raise funds for worthy community causes in and around the Boston area, but I do fall on the side of purity of purpose when it comes to this race. We can find other ways to use the marathon to support those causes without diluting the field.

kim levandoski said on March 29th, 2009 at 12:44 pm

Thanks Adam, I have been feeling a bit “guilty” as of late because I am running Boston for the pure enjoyment of the experience. Not for a PR, not for anything other than to relax and have fun. And strangely, I have been feeling like this is a disservice to the day.

Your comment about what makes Boston different is that everyone has already put in the hard work to get there, there is nothing to worry about and celebrate the accomplishments.

As Facebook says, “I like this!”……thanks for putting it into perspective!

Don said on March 29th, 2009 at 2:28 pm

Anyone in the world can qualify to race in the Boston Marathon. However only Americans can purchase the official souvenir clothing online. I sure hope that it is not all sold out by the time my plane lands at Logan Airport.

Coach Adam said on March 29th, 2009 at 2:34 pm

Don, sounds like a business opportunity. What’s the vig for US folks purchasing in advance for our international compadres?

Jamie said on March 29th, 2009 at 5:05 pm

It sounds like Boston was just on the “bucket list” of things to check off for dumprunner.

Living in Mass, I can name a dozen people that I’ve met in the last few months that have run Boston. But people that have actually qualified and not for charity? That is a completely different story and quickly changes the tone of the conversation. Granted raising $3k for charity is no easy task, but my eyes definitely widen and my respect level jumps a little when I realize that they did it the hard way and qualified.

Charity runners definitely change things, but in no way does it take anything away from those that have put in all the hard running miles to get there without laying down a fat check.

Coach Adam said on March 29th, 2009 at 5:24 pm

Jamie,
Thanks or the insight. I agree raising $3K is no easy task for some, for others they simply write a check but your perspective on the effort of those that really work to raise funds to get there is much appreciated.

Shawn Parker said on March 29th, 2009 at 6:57 pm

I am going to Boston and I am racing under a charity organization.

I am not writing a check either. I have commitment from people to write a check or donate based on my finishing the marathon.

I totally agree that those who qualified on time alone are the rocks stars of Marathon and I lucky to even share the same air with them that day

As a member of the team sponsored by the Lance Armstrong Foundation, I am hoping to not only raise money for Cancer Awareness but to let other Cancer victims know that life is not over because of the disease.

I will be running in the back of the pack but running with a purpose.

dumprunner said on March 30th, 2009 at 8:04 am

Jamie, I don’t even have a bucket list. . I was very much into the whole race beforehand and was genuinely excited at the opprotunity to participate in one of the world’s great races. I actually hesitated in writing the original post because I know it is not the “in” opinion for a runner to have about the Boston Marathon.

As for Adam’s thoughts. I didn’t even consider the field in my opinion of the race. For starters, while I recognize the quality of the field, I was surprised at the number of people who simpy run Boston as opposed to race it. Which it perfectly okay considering the feat and the course. Some people choose to look at as a graduation ceremony as opposed to a final exam. In that case, the BQ is a double edged sword. The Start Line is the finish line. Also, given the breadth, of the field with it’s sliding scale I only felt like at the same level as the few waves around me. Finally, the feeling of the runners around me harkened back to my experiences running in HS and College, it is rare in my daily life now but not new.

I recognize that Boston is special and is certainly one of the best running events in the world.
My post was more a response to “Boston is the Greatest” sentiment .

Coach Adam said on March 30th, 2009 at 8:17 am

graduation ceremony vs final exam. That’s a much more succinct way of laying out those two very different but equally valid perspectives.

SpeedySasquatch said on March 30th, 2009 at 11:53 am

Growing up North of Boston and having watched the race for years and years I have always wanted to do this race, but never thought that I would ever do it, I just didn’t think I could ever run for that long or that far. So, now, here I am, and only a few weeks away from this beast! I qualified two years ago and got hurt killing last year’s chance to run with Avi (aka Speedy Elf), but this is MY year. I’ve waited two years to dominate this course and I fully intend on giving it my best effort, no matter what condition it is in. This is a chance for me to run a race that my Father always wanted to run, but his knees wouldn’t let him. I get to run in front of kids I’ve coached in soccer, people I grew up with and I get to add that badge of honor to my running resume. It has been in my goal since I started running regularly 5 years ago or so and I am just so excited to be a part of it.

Farrah said on March 31st, 2009 at 3:48 am

I agree with Kim- I have also been feeling a bit “guilty” because I am running Boston for the pure enjoyment of the experience. I have not trained as I have for other marathons and am feeling a bit unprepared for anything but a relaxing run. So it helped to have you remind me that I’ve already put the hard work in to get there because I really did.

Regarding participation thru a charity- I’m indifferent. I know that I earned Boston and that’s all that matters. If others want to run Boston and the only way for them to do it is thru a charity, what do I care? At the end of the day, what’s important to me is what counts.

Mike Wall said on July 21st, 2009 at 11:21 am

I wanted to get in touch with Coach Adam in response to a comment he made on Twitter, but there is no Contact information on this site. How can I get in touch with Adam?



Leave a Reply